Blog Layout

Short-Term Rentals vs Long-Term Rentals: Which is More Lucrative?

Feb 22, 2024

Are you a property owner in Boise, Idaho, exploring the lucrative world of rental investments? As leading property management experts in Boise, we understand the importance of choosing the right rental strategy to maximize your returns. So, what are the key differences between short-term and long-term rentals? We'll answer the most common questions and considerations to help you make informed decisions for your Boise investment property. Whether it be listing on Airbnb, VRBO, CozyCozy, RentCafe, Vacasa or Furnished Finder, we're here to help!


In Idaho, short-term rentals (STR) typically refer to accommodations rented out for periods of fewer than 30 consecutive days. These rentals include vacation homes, Airbnb listings, and other transient lodging options. The short-term Boise rental license fee is $80 every year. It's essential for property owners to familiarize themselves with local regulations and zoning laws governing short-term rentals in Boise and ensure compliance with legal requirements.


Is Airbnb Legal in Boise, Idaho?

Yes, Airbnb and other short-term rental platforms are legal in Boise, Idaho. However, property owners must adhere to specific regulations and licensing requirements imposed by the city. The licensing requirements for Boise came into effect on May 2022 and need to be renewed annually. There has also been discussing on stricter policy to enforce this requirement in recent months.


Is Boise a Good Airbnb Market?

Boise, Idaho, is widely regarded as a thriving Airbnb market, attracting both leisure and business travelers throughout the year. With its vibrant culture, scenic beauty, and growing tourism industry, Boise offers ample opportunities for property owners to capitalize on short-term rental demand and generate substantial rental income. However, it is important to consider the negative impact an increased short-term rental market can have on Boise, possible new regulations and over saturation of the market before pursuing this strategy. For a detailed report on what your property could rent for, visit our Rental Analysis or Market Pulse Page.


What Makes More Money: Short-Term or Long-Term Rentals?

When it comes to rental income, the debate between long-term and short-term rentals (STR) is ongoing. While short-term rentals often command higher nightly rates, long-term rentals offer consistent, steady income with fewer vacancies. Factors such as location, property type, and demand can significantly impact profitability for both rental strategies. There are just simply too many factors to consider to answer this question directly, many of which are unknown for the future. It is important to fully understand all the risks associated with each strategy and make sure you are comfortable with those risks.


What are the Negative Effects of Short-Term Rentals?

While short-term rentals can be lucrative, they may also pose challenges and negative effects for communities and neighborhoods. Common concerns in Boise include noise disturbances, parking issues, increased traffic, security risks, higher energy consumption, increased waste, lower housing supply and disruptions to residential areas. Boise investment property owners must balance the benefits of short-term rentals with the potential impact on local communities and quality of life.


Are Short-Term Rentals Recession-Proof?

While short-term rentals have historically performed well during economic downturns, they are not entirely recession-proof. Market fluctuations, changes in travel patterns, and external factors can impact short-term rental demand and profitability. As we saw from COVID, unforeseen circumstance can dramatically affect the profitability of Airbnb's and VRBO's in Boise. Property owners should diversify their rental portfolios and implement strategic management practices to mitigate risks during economic downturns. Read our blog on the Boise housing market boom and migration of residents from neighboring states.


Why are Cities Banning Airbnb?

Some cities have implemented restrictions or outright bans on Airbnb and other short-term rentals due to concerns over housing affordability, neighborhood stability, and compliance with local regulations. These restrictions aim to address issues such as housing shortages, rising rents, and the commercialization of residential properties. With the City of Boise moving to strictly enforce their short-term rental licensing requirements, there is no telling what the future holds from a regulatory standpoint.


Are Short-Term Rentals a Good Investment?

Short-term rentals in Boise can be a lucrative investment opportunity for property owners willing to invest time and resources into effective management strategies. However, success in the short-term rental (STR) market requires careful planning, diligent property management, and a thorough understanding of local regulations and market dynamics. Although it may seem attractive from a gross revenue perspective, short-term rentals can require much more work and incur added costs.


Is the Airbnb Boom Over?

Since Airbnb was founded in 2008, it has seemed to grow in popularity every year. In mid 2023, there were many reports of short-term rental markets falling and revenues being slashed, to what degree, is still debated. There has definitely been a saturation and pull back in many markets. With increased fees, long check-in and check-out processes, need to communicate with hosts as well as general responsibilities associated with Airbnb's, hotels are once again becoming a popular choice for leisure and business travelers alike. While the initial boom in Airbnb and short-term rentals may have stabilized, the industry continues to evolve and adapt to changing consumer preferences, travel trends and new regulation. With proper management and strategic marketing, property owners can still capitalize on the growing demand for short-term accommodations in Boise and other desirable destinations. Here's another great article on the latest after the so called "collapse". Link


What is the Best Software for Short-Term Rentals?

For property owners seeking efficient management solutions for short-term rentals, several software platforms cater to short-term rental management and vacation rental management. Popular options include Airbnb's own management tools, as well as third-party platforms like Hostaway, OwnerRez, Guesty, Hostfully, and Your Porter App. These software solutions streamline booking management, guest communication, and property maintenance for seamless operation.


What are Mid Term Rentals?

Mid or medium term rentals are rental properties that have tenancies from more than 30 days to less than 12 months. Tenants for this type of rental can include travel nurses, business professionals on a work assignment, divorcee's or individuals and families that need temporary housing before purchasing or moving into their own home. The average length of tenancy is 3 months. It has become an increasingly popular concept as younger generations' personal and professional goals have shifted and the idea of flexibility and mobility are more desired. Mid term rental properties, as you would expect, are in between short and long term rentals in relation to costs, nightly revenue, work required and turnover. Furnished Finder is a great tool to use if interested in this particular strategy.


Should I Hire a Manager for my Airbnb?

Deciding whether to hire short-term property management for your Boise Airbnb property is a significant consideration for property owners. While managing your Boise Airbnb listing independently offers greater control and potentially higher profits, it also requires considerable time, effort, and expertise in guest communication, property maintenance, and marketing. Hiring a reputable Airbnb property management company can alleviate the burden of day-to-day management tasks, ensuring seamless guest experiences, optimal occupancy rates, and enhanced property performance. A short-term Property manager handles everything from guest inquiries and check-ins to cleaning and maintenance, allowing Boise rental property owners to enjoy passive income without the stress and hassle of hands-on investment property management. Ultimately, the decision to hire a vacation rental manager for your Airbnb investment property depends on your availability, resources, and investment goals. Consulting with experienced property management Boise professionals can help you evaluate your options and make informed decisions that align with your needs and objectives. Be sure to read our blog on hiring a property manager in Boise.


What are the best neighborhoods for Short-Term Rentals in Boise?

Choosing the right neighborhood for a short-term rental investment is critical for success. Prime locations near tourist attractions, amenities, walkable areas, great restaurants, and transportation hubs drive demand and occupancy rates. In Boise, the North End and Bench have seen a lot of short-term rental property growth due to their access to the Boise River Greenbelt, Hyde Park, downtown, foothills and some of our top restaurants and bars! The new zoning code in Boise has also opened up opportunities for short-term rentals in these areas through allowing commercial spaces for coffee shops in residential neighborhoods and easing ADU restrictions.


How Do You Succeed in Short-Term Rentals?

With all the competition in the Boise short-term rental (STR) market, it can be difficult to stand out and prosper. To succeed in short-term rentals, property owners must not only prioritize guest satisfaction, maintain high standards of cleanliness and hospitality, and leverage technology to streamline operations, but also go above and beyond what all other competitors are offering. Additionally, effective pricing strategies, targeted marketing efforts, and proactive property maintenance are essential for maximizing occupancy rates and rental income.



In conclusion, whether you opt for short-term or long-term rentals in Boise, Idaho, success in the rental market requires careful consideration of various factors, including market demand, property characteristics, and management resources. As experienced Boise property management professionals, we're here to provide expert guidance and support to help you achieve your investment goals. Contact us today to learn more about our comprehensive property management services tailored to your needs and objectives.

Boise housing market, cash flow vs appreciation, boise investing
03 May, 2024
When buy and hold investors consider purchasing a new investment property, cash flow or appreciation are the two most common goals. They provide two very different outcomes, which means they attract two different types of investors. Simply put and without getting too deep into complex market factors; as market conditions ebb and flow, markets become more or less suited to provide cash flow or appreciation. So let's dive into each or these concepts and discover which is most appropriate in the Boise housing market.
golf in boise, boise golf, golf boise, hillcrest country club, quail hollow.
01 May, 2024
Boise may not attract the attention that Northern Idaho gets, with courses like Black Rock, Gozzer Ranch and the Coeur D'Alene Golf Club with it's famous floating green, only accessible by ferry. However, golf in Boise will satisfy all golf nuts. From flat sprawling fairways to holes with extreme elevation changes, there's always variety and a challenge around the corner. Also, don't be surprised if you encounter deer, coyotes and other beautiful wildlife during your rounds. If you're looking for things to do in Boise, golf should be near the top of your list!
painting, home painting, diy painting, rental property improvement, investment property upgrade
19 Apr, 2024
The concept of return on investment (ROI) when dealing with rental properties is often looked at in an extremely simplified manner. ROI for rental property improvements is calculated as the total cost of upgrades divided by the difference in rent received over a 12 month period. However, this is not the full picture. Property improvements can have many other knock on effects such as reduced maintenance, higher quality tenants who in turn take better care of the property as well as increased tenant satisfaction resulting in lower vacancy. (See our blog post on Increasing Tenant Satisfaction) It's impossible to fully quantify all the outcomes that property improvements will create, but we are able to differentiate between effective and non-effective upgrades.It's important to strike the balance between creating a beautiful and appealing living space, that increases rentability, with a functional rental that reduces maintenance and general wear and tear.
senior hiking, boise retirement, retire in boise, senior housing
16 Apr, 2024
With it's expansive outdoors, city-like amenities, friendly communities and tax friendly policies, Boise is a great place for seniors to live. There are many factors to consider when deciding how you'd like to spend retirement and the golden years, the most important being housing. There are many different routes and options when considering senior housing and it's important to understand the pros and cons of each. So let's explore all things senior housing and see which option is the best fit for you.
ADU, ADU in Boise, Boise zoning code
06 Apr, 2024
Boise and the Treasure Valley are witnessing a shift with the rising popularity of Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs). Driving around Boise, you'll often see a garage or old workshop currently being converted into an ADU, not to mention the ever increasing AirBnB listings. This has much to do with the City of Boise, in an effort to address housing affordability, becoming a very ADU friendly city. In the modern zoning code, which was introduced in December 2023, many of the requirements pertaining to ADU's were eased, making them that much more enticing to homeowners. So, what are ADUs and should you consider one? Let's take a look at all the pro's, cons and other details to consider.
boise landscaping, rental property landscaping, rentals landscaping, tenant yard maintenance
29 Mar, 2024
Love for the outdoors and nature runs deep in Boisean's blood. In fact, many people moving from California to Boise are looking for just that; space, greenery and an escape from the same copy paste, hardscape landscaping found in most rental properties. While there are definitely advantages to minimalist, low-maintenance designs, the trade-off with tenant appeal needs to be considered, especially in a market where green spaces and back yard sanctuaries are so valued. Your rental property's landscaping should not be seen as a chore or responsibility, but as a tool to attract top tenants, increase tenant satisfaction and reduce vacancy. At Bluebird Property Management, we recognize the importance of balancing aesthetics with practicality, to create inviting outdoor spaces and enhance property value, while ultimately increasing your rental property's cash flow.
Boise, Boise capital building, Boise housing market, boise real estate investing,
22 Mar, 2024
Boise can be an exceptional market for real estate investors. Despite all the attention the Boise housing market has received in the past few years, it maintains many of the fundamentals of what investors desire when considering investment markets. From job growth and good schools to low crime and excellent quality of life; One thing's for sure, the future of Boise is exciting! Here we discuss a few of the changes coming to the treasure valley and decide if Boise is a good place to invest.
boise pet owners, pets in rentals, allowing pets in rental property, pets in boise,
15 Mar, 2024
Boise is a gateway to the outdoors and endless wilderness. This attracts many renters to the area with a love for adventuring, getting outdoors and owning a furry friend. As a Boise property management company rooted in the community, we understand the importance of finding the perfect balance between accommodating furry companions and maintaining your rental properties. So, let's discuss pros, cons and everything you need to know about allowing renters with pets in Boise.
Boise tenants, tenant retention, keeping good tenants, rental property, boise property management
08 Mar, 2024
As a property management company serving the vibrant community of Boise, we understand the importance of retaining good tenants. Keeping happy and respectful tenants not only ensures a steady stream of rental income and low vacancy but also improves the care for your property. They are arguably the most important factor when it comes to a rental property investment and it is vital to treat them as such. In this blog post, we'll discuss effective strategies that landlords in Boise can implement to encourage long-term tenant retention. These include good communication, capital improvements, rent increases, renewal incentives, maintenance response.
Boise foothills, Boise neighborhoods, View of City of Boise, Where's the best place to live in Boise
29 Feb, 2024
Where's the best place to live in Boise? This is a question a lot of people who move to Boise from California or Washington find themselves asking. If you're considering a move to Boise, this is your guide. Boise's vibrant neighborhoods offer something for everyone. Whether you're a young professional, retiree, family, outdoor enthusiast, culture buff, or foodie, Boise has it all. So, let's take a stroll through the different areas and find your perfect neighborhood!
More Posts
Share by: